How did they do it? And why have been so many unbiased analysts so improper? I put these inquiries to Parker Poling, the govt director of the Nationwide Republican Congressional Committee, the social gathering’s House marketing campaign arm.

Cillizza: Each political handicapper predicted losses for House Republicans on Tuesday. That did not occur. Have been you stunned? Why or why not?

Poling: We have been stunned however not shocked. Basing your knowledgeable opinions on public polls or knowledge that’s selectively shared with you is a basically flawed solution to handicap, however we’ll see what accountability measures exist for that.

Clearly the Democrat convention is beginning their very own post-mortem to attempt to determine the place their knowledge operation went improper. Our polling and modeled knowledge of absentee and early vote returns mentioned we realistically had a path to choose up seats. At our closing workers assembly earlier than the election, our consensus was that we’d web +four seats. Our knowledge confirmed that we have been inside putting distance in almost each aggressive race, with most of them trending in our course. The President closed sturdy in our battleground districts and our candidates had their very own distinctive attraction that received late deciding voters.

Cillizza: Did you see a single message or concern break by with voters in swing districts? Was there an assault that notably damage Democrats?

Poling: In case you put all of the messages right into a single broad class, it could be the excessive leftward lurch of the Democrat Celebration.

That was messaged in several methods in several districts. In New York state, bail reform was extraordinarily unpopular and meshed nicely with defund the police, so a public security angle was the only. In some districts, it was “Medicare for All” and the lack of non-public medical health insurance. In plenty of suburban districts, we talked about pocketbook points like larger taxes underneath Biden. And in different districts, we targeted on the extremism of the “Inexperienced New Deal.” And in south Florida particularly, it was socialism extra broadly. All of these messages match inside the rubric of extremism.

Cillizza: President Trump was a serious anchor for House Republicans in the suburbs in the 2018 midterms. Why wasn’t he this time?

Poling: I disagree with the premise of your query.

A lot of President Trump’s voters (8.5 million, to be extra precise) stayed residence in 2018. These are by and enormous votes for House Republicans as nicely, which might have greater than stored us in the majority. Sure, base Democrats in the midterms have been motivated by animus towards the President to prove, however Democrat candidates ran and received as a result of that they had no voting report that was tied to Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi and the far left of their social gathering. Their candidates bought to painting themselves as no matter they needed and that helped them win unbiased and persuadable voters.

When the President’s supporters did not match base Democrats turnout they usually received independents, it was straightforward to see how they received in each Trump territory and districts Hillary Clinton carried in 2016. They confirmed up once more in 2020 and independents broke to our candidates when these Democrats uncovered their ties to the excessive of their social gathering.

Cillizza: Polling was, once more, means off — notably at the House district degree. Why? And the way do you repair it?

Poling: Not all polling was improper. There are polls both the NRCC, our candidates or allied teams like the Congressional Management Fund launched publicly in each certainly one of our pickup districts that confirmed the place we’d win.

I believe there should be an actual reckoning in the media and amongst the prognosticators about why they believed Democrat partisan polling greater than Republican partisan polling. Normally, most of our aggressive races have been inside the margin of error. Democrats stored saying they have been beating a few of our incumbents, and our knowledge was not displaying that.

Cillizza: End this sentence: “The most important lesson for House Republicans out of the 2020 election was ________.” Now, clarify.

Poling: “The most important lesson for House Republicans out of the 2020 election was it is a center-right nation.”

The American folks, and notably swing voters, need to elect representatives who mirror the values this nation was based on. They’ll reject radical propositions like defunding the police and destroying the American economic system. They need to safely reopen the nation. These are the values mirrored by House Republicans and our candidates.